Skip to content
Rubric AdvisorsRubric Advisors

By

Investing & Markets

Private Credit and Direct Lending: How It Works and What Can Go Wrong

Private credit is lending by non-bank funds directly to companies, usually at floating rates, trading liquidity and transparency for extra yield.

Private Credit and Direct Lending: How It Works and What Can Go Wrong

1 / 7

What is private credit?

  • Private credit is lending by funds and other non-bank lenders directly to companies, with loans negotiated privately rather than sold as public bonds.
  • The largest segment, direct lending, mostly finances mid-sized businesses owned by private equity firms.
  • Loans are usually floating rate and held to maturity rather than traded, so prices are estimated, not observed daily.
  • The market grew after 2008 as banks pulled back from riskier lending and borrowers valued speed and certainty of terms.

Full Guide

What is private credit?

  • Private credit is lending by funds and other non-bank lenders directly to companies, with loans negotiated privately rather than sold as public bonds.
  • The largest segment, direct lending, mostly finances mid-sized businesses owned by private equity firms.
  • Loans are usually floating rate and held to maturity rather than traded, so prices are estimated, not observed daily.
  • The market grew after 2008 as banks pulled back from riskier lending and borrowers valued speed and certainty of terms.

Strategies under the private credit label

  • Senior and unitranche loans sit first in line for repayment and are secured by the borrower's assets.
  • Second-lien and mezzanine loans rank lower, charge more, and may pay part of their interest in additional debt (PIK) or include warrants.
  • Asset-based lending is secured by receivables, equipment, or other specific collateral rather than overall company cash flow.
  • Specialty and opportunistic strategies include venture debt, royalty financing, and buying loans of distressed companies.

Where does the return come from, and what eats into it?

  • Lenders earn a base rate plus a negotiated spread, along with upfront fees or discounts and prepayment penalties.
  • Default losses, management and incentive fees, and the cost of any fund-level borrowing all reduce what investors keep.
  • Because rates float, income tends to fall when rates fall, while high rates can strain borrowers' ability to pay interest.
  • A rising share of interest paid in kind rather than cash can be an early sign that borrowers are under stress.

What are the main risks?

  • Credit risk: borrowers are often highly leveraged, and senior status reduces but doesn't remove the chance of losses.
  • Liquidity risk: drawdown funds can lock capital for years, and semi-liquid funds can limit or suspend redemptions when many investors want out.
  • Valuation risk: infrequent, model-based pricing can make reported volatility look lower than the underlying economic risk.
  • Terms risk: competition for deals can loosen covenants and underwriting, and results vary widely from one manager to another.

How do individuals invest, and how is it taxed?

  • Publicly traded business development companies (BDCs) trade daily but their prices can swing well above or below reported asset value.
  • Non-traded BDCs and interval funds offer periodic liquidity, often a set percentage per quarter, and may impose suitability or income minimums.
  • Private drawdown funds are generally limited to accredited investors or qualified purchasers and may issue K-1s.
  • Distributions are mostly taxed as ordinary income rather than qualified dividends, which affects which account type many investors use.

Questions for evaluating a manager

  • How has the manager handled defaults and workouts in past downturns, and how are losses and non-accruals reported?
  • Where do deals come from, and how concentrated is the portfolio by sector, sponsor, and borrower?
  • How much fund-level leverage is used, and what are the redemption terms and gates?
  • What are total fees, including incentive fees, and how are loans valued between sales?

Key takeaways

  • Private credit offers floating-rate income in exchange for credit risk, illiquidity, and less transparency than public bonds.
  • Smooth reported values don't mean low risk; losses can appear late and all at once.
  • Vehicle choice determines liquidity, fees, and tax reporting as much as the loans themselves.
  • This is educational only and not a recommendation; private investments can lose value, including principal.