Skip to content
Rubric AdvisorsRubric Advisors

By

Investing & Markets

Private Credit vs. Public Bonds: Yield, Liquidity, and Risk Trade-Offs

Private credit is lending to companies outside public bond markets. It may pay more but is illiquid, harder to value, and carries higher fees.

Private Credit vs. Public Bonds: Yield, Liquidity, and Risk Trade-Offs

1 / 7

What is private credit?

  • Private credit is lending to companies by funds and other non-bank lenders, negotiated privately instead of issued in public bond markets.
  • Common strategies include direct lending to middle-market companies, mezzanine debt, distressed debt, and specialty finance.
  • Many loans are floating-rate, with interest set as a benchmark rate plus a spread.
  • Borrowers often accept higher rates in exchange for speed, flexibility, and a single negotiated lender group.

Full Guide

What is private credit?

  • Private credit is lending to companies by funds and other non-bank lenders, negotiated privately instead of issued in public bond markets.
  • Common strategies include direct lending to middle-market companies, mezzanine debt, distressed debt, and specialty finance.
  • Many loans are floating-rate, with interest set as a benchmark rate plus a spread.
  • Borrowers often accept higher rates in exchange for speed, flexibility, and a single negotiated lender group.

How do public bonds differ?

  • Public bonds, such as Treasuries, corporate bonds, and municipal bonds, trade in markets with regular price quotes.
  • Many public issuers file reports with the SEC and carry ratings from credit rating agencies.
  • Investors can usually sell public bonds or bond funds on any business day, though prices may be poor in stressed markets.
  • Fixed-rate public bonds carry more interest rate risk than floating-rate loans, while short-term and floating-rate bonds carry less.

Does private credit pay more, and why?

  • Private loans typically carry higher stated yields to compensate for illiquidity, complexity, and borrower risk.
  • Borrowers are often smaller or more leveraged companies than typical investment-grade issuers.
  • Management fees, incentive fees, and fund expenses reduce what investors actually receive.
  • Loan values are set by models and appraisals rather than trading, so reported volatility can understate real risk.

How can individual investors access private credit?

  • Publicly traded business development companies (BDCs) lend to private companies and trade on exchanges, often at a premium or discount to net asset value.
  • Non-traded BDCs and interval funds offer periodic liquidity; interval funds repurchase 5% to 25% of shares at set intervals, typically quarterly.
  • Private credit funds structured as limited partnerships are generally limited to accredited investors or qualified purchasers and lock up capital for years.
  • BDCs can use more leverage than traditional mutual funds, which magnifies both income and losses.

What are the main risks of private credit?

  • Credit risk: defaults tend to rise in recessions, and loans to leveraged borrowers can lose substantial value.
  • Liquidity risk: redemptions may be limited, prorated, or suspended when many investors want out at once.
  • Valuation risk: infrequent, model-based pricing may lag real conditions.
  • Manager risk: underwriting, workout skill, and fees vary widely, and the asset class has grown quickly without being tested in every type of downturn.

What questions help evaluate a private credit fund?

  • How has the manager handled defaults and restructurings, and how are problem loans reported?
  • How are loans valued, how often, and by whom?
  • What are total fees, including incentive fees and fund-level leverage costs?
  • What are the exact redemption terms, and what happens if requests exceed the limit?

Key takeaways

  • Private credit trades liquidity and transparency for potentially higher income.
  • Public bonds offer daily pricing and easier exits but carry their own rate and credit risks.
  • BDCs, interval funds, and private funds differ sharply in liquidity, leverage, fees, and eligibility.
  • Valuation methods, fees, and redemption terms deserve as much scrutiny as the stated yield.