Skip to content
Rubric AdvisorsRubric Advisors

By

Investing & Markets

Value vs. Growth Investing: How the Two Styles Differ

Value stocks trade at low prices relative to earnings or book value; growth stocks at premiums for expected growth. Leadership between them shifts.

Value vs. Growth Investing: How the Two Styles Differ

1 / 6

What is the difference between value and growth stocks?

  • Value stocks trade at lower prices relative to measures such as earnings, book value, or cash flow.
  • Growth stocks trade at higher multiples because investors expect faster growth in earnings or revenue.
  • Index providers classify stocks with their own formulas, and many stocks are split between value and growth indexes.
  • The labels describe valuation, not quality; either group can include strong or weak businesses.

Full Guide

What is the difference between value and growth stocks?

  • Value stocks trade at lower prices relative to measures such as earnings, book value, or cash flow.
  • Growth stocks trade at higher multiples because investors expect faster growth in earnings or revenue.
  • Index providers classify stocks with their own formulas, and many stocks are split between value and growth indexes.
  • The labels describe valuation, not quality; either group can include strong or weak businesses.

Which metrics define each style?

  • Price-to-earnings (P/E) compares a stock's price with its earnings per share.
  • Price-to-book (P/B) compares market value with accounting net assets, which can understate companies built on software, brands, or patents.
  • Growth measures use historical and forecast growth in sales or earnings, and forecasts can be wrong.
  • Different metrics can place the same stock in different styles.

What does research say about a value premium?

  • Research by Eugene Fama and Kenneth French in the early 1990s found value stocks had historically earned higher average returns than growth stocks.
  • Researchers disagree on why: compensation for extra risk, or investor behavior that misprices stocks.
  • The pattern hasn't been consistent, and growth stocks have led for long stretches.
  • Past style patterns may not persist.

What risks does each style carry?

  • Value traps: a stock can look cheap because the business is in lasting decline.
  • Growth stock prices depend heavily on earnings expected far in the future, so they can fall sharply if growth disappoints or interest rates rise.
  • Style indexes can be concentrated in a few sectors, such as technology in growth indexes.
  • Long periods of trailing the market can lead investors to abandon a style at a poor time.

How do investors combine the two styles?

  • A total-market index fund holds both in proportion to their market value.
  • Tilts toward one style use style index or factor funds; overlap and sector exposure are worth checking.
  • Rebalancing between styles keeps a tilt from drifting after one style has a long run.
  • Tech employees with large holdings of company stock often already carry significant growth exposure.

Key takeaways

  • Value and growth are valuation-based styles, and index providers define them differently.
  • Research found a historical value premium, but it has been inconsistent and its cause is debated.
  • Value traps and valuation-driven drawdowns are the main style-specific risks.
  • Your existing holdings, especially employer stock, shape which style you already own.