Breakeven Analysis and Discount Rates

Calculate how many years of annuity payments equal the lump sum amount Breakeven typically falls between 10 and 20 years depending on assumptions Higher interest rates reduce the lump sum amount offered by the plan Timing your election around rate changes can materially affect the payout

Survivor Benefit Options

Joint-and-survivor annuity continues payments to a spouse after your death Survivor options (50%, 75%, 100%) reduce your monthly payment proportionally Lump sum offers flexibility — remaining assets pass to any beneficiary you choose Single-life annuity pays the most per month but stops entirely at your death

Inflation Risk of a Fixed Annuity

Most pension annuities pay a fixed dollar amount with no inflation adjustment At 3% inflation, purchasing power drops roughly 25% after 10 years Cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs) are rare in private-sector pensions A lump sum invested with growth potential may better preserve purchasing power

Investment Risk of the Lump Sum

Taking a lump sum shifts investment risk entirely to you Poor returns or excessive withdrawals can deplete the balance prematurely Market downturns early in retirement (sequence-of-returns risk) are especially harmful Disciplined withdrawal strategy is critical to making a lump sum last

Tax Treatment and Rollover Considerations

Rolling a lump sum directly to a traditional IRA defers all taxes Taking cash triggers ordinary income tax on the full amount in one year Annuity payments are taxed as ordinary income each year they are received Roth IRA conversion of a lump sum accelerates taxes but creates tax-free growth

Making the Decision — Key Factors

Good health and family longevity history may favor the annuity Other guaranteed income (Social Security, rental) reduces the need for an annuity Some plans allow a partial lump sum with a reduced annuity payment PBGC insurance protects annuities if the plan sponsor becomes insolvent

Pension Lump Sum vs Annuity — Evaluating Your Payout Options

Curated by: Rubric Advisors

1 / 7

How Each Payout Option Works

Annuity provides guaranteed monthly income for life from the pension plan
Lump sum transfers the full present value to you as a single payment
Lump sum can be rolled into an IRA to defer taxes or taken as taxable income
Some plans offer only one option — not all pensions provide a choice

Retirement Planning Public Markets Our Approach

Try Our Free Tools

Retirement Calculator Withdrawal Simulator Inflation Calculator

How Each Payout Option Works

Breakeven Analysis and Discount Rates

Survivor Benefit Options

Inflation Risk of a Fixed Annuity

Investment Risk of the Lump Sum

Tax Treatment and Rollover Considerations

Making the Decision — Key Factors

Related Topics

Retirement Income Distribution Strategy: Account Sequencing

Annuity Types: Fixed, Variable, and Indexed

401(k) Withdrawal Rules

How Each Payout Option Works

Breakeven Analysis and Discount Rates

Survivor Benefit Options

Inflation Risk of a Fixed Annuity

Investment Risk of the Lump Sum

Tax Treatment and Rollover Considerations

Making the Decision — Key Factors

Related Topics

Retirement Income Distribution Strategy: Account Sequencing

Annuity Types: Fixed, Variable, and Indexed

401(k) Withdrawal Rules