Curated by: Rubric Advisors
Equity Compensation
What to Do at an Overvalued Startup
This article provides strategic guidance for startup employees dealing with underwater stock options at overvalued companies, emphasizing data collection, scenario analysis, and intentional decision-making during market downturns.
What to Do at an Overvalued Startup
1 / 7
Stay Calm and Intentional
- Remember that startups are a long-term game requiring decades to flourish
- Great businesses take time to develop, so avoid making rash decisions
- Down markets can be opportunities to differentiate yourself and build skills
- Focus on working with conviction on something you believe in
Try Our Free Tools
Full Guide
Stay Calm and Intentional
- Remember that startups are a long-term game requiring decades to flourish
- Great businesses take time to develop, so avoid making rash decisions
- Down markets can be opportunities to differentiate yourself and build skills
- Focus on working with conviction on something you believe in
Gather Critical Equity Information
- Understand what type of equity you own: ISOs, NSOs, or RSUs
- Know your strike price, vesting schedule, and post-termination exercise window
- Learn the latest 409A valuation and preferred price per share
- Talk to your manager for important insights and proactive guidance
Assess Business Health Factors
- Evaluate current business metrics, profitability, and overall company performance
- Understand the company's liquidity plan and potential IPO timeline
- Research public market comparables to gauge realistic valuations
- Assess whether you believe in the leadership team's ability
Analyze Multiple Valuation Scenarios
- Compare preferred price, 409A valuation, and secondary market trading values
- Consider how lower valuations may impact your financial goals
- Understand that lower 409A valuations reduce taxable obligations when exercising
- Remember secondary markets are inefficient but provide valuation insights
Exercise Options Strategic Considerations
- Lower bargain element may create tax-optimal timing for exercising options
- Only exercise if you believe valuation will exceed strike price plus taxes
- Remember startup equity is risky and often correlated to net worth
- Consider additional upside negotiations as you prove business value
Alternative Career Path Options
- If you don't believe in company future, consider finding new employment
- Now may be optimal time to start new company or find stable job
- Avoid selling shares on secondary market due to lack of demand
- Decision depends on your personal risk tolerance and priorities
Key Takeaways
- Collect complete equity and business health data before making any decisions
- Write a decision memo to yourself to minimize regret and clarify motives
- Consider exercising options during lower 409A valuations for tax optimization
- Focus on long-term career building rather than short-term equity concerns
Related Topics
Should You Early Exercise Your Stock Options?
Early exercising stock options can save significant taxes, but it's not always the right call. We walk through the trade-offs, tax implications, and when it makes sense to act before vesting.
Equity CompensationA Framework for Exercising Stock Options
This article provides a comprehensive framework for tech employees to decide whether to exercise stock options, balancing investment potential with risk management and tax implications.
Equity CompensationEarly Exercising and 83(b) Elections
Early exercising allows employees to purchase unvested stock options upfront to minimize taxes, but requires filing an 83(b) election within 30 days.