Skip to content
Rubric AdvisorsRubric Advisors

By

Equity Compensation

How to Evaluate the Equity in a Tech Job Offer

Equity in an offer is worth a range, not a number. Value depends on award type, strike price, dilution, liquidation preferences, and whether an exit occurs.

How to Evaluate the Equity in a Tech Job Offer

1 / 7

What is the equity in a job offer actually worth?

  • An equity grant is a claim on future value whose worth depends on award type, price paid, dilution, investor preferences, and an eventual exit.
  • Public-company RSUs have a market price today; private-company options and RSUs do not, and they may never become sellable.
  • Private equity can end up worth nothing, so it is safer to think in scenarios than in a single headline figure.
  • Comparing offers on a risk-adjusted basis often changes which one looks better.

Full Guide

What is the equity in a job offer actually worth?

  • An equity grant is a claim on future value whose worth depends on award type, price paid, dilution, investor preferences, and an eventual exit.
  • Public-company RSUs have a market price today; private-company options and RSUs do not, and they may never become sellable.
  • Private equity can end up worth nothing, so it is safer to think in scenarios than in a single headline figure.
  • Comparing offers on a risk-adjusted basis often changes which one looks better.

How do RSUs, ISOs, and NSOs pay out and get taxed?

  • RSUs are generally taxed as wages when they vest; private-company RSUs often use a second trigger, such as an IPO, before tax is due.
  • NSOs create ordinary income on the spread between fair market value and strike price when you exercise.
  • ISOs owe no regular income tax at exercise, but the spread counts toward the alternative minimum tax (AMT).
  • ISO shares held at least two years from grant and one year from exercise can qualify for long-term capital gains; confirm your facts with a CPA.

Which questions should you ask the recruiter?

  • What type of award is it, how many shares or units, and what is the strike price and date of the latest 409A valuation?
  • How many fully diluted shares are outstanding, so you can calculate your ownership percentage?
  • What was the last preferred share price, and how large are the liquidation preferences ahead of common stock?
  • What are the vesting schedule, cliff, refresh policy, and post-termination exercise window, and is early exercise allowed?

How can you build a value range?

  • Multiply your ownership percentage by several possible exit values, including one where common stock receives nothing.
  • Subtract investors' liquidation preferences first, since preferred shareholders are typically paid before common in a sale.
  • Reduce your percentage for future funding rounds, which usually dilute existing holders.
  • Subtract the cost to exercise and the taxes owed; option terms usually run up to 10 years but often expire about 90 days after you leave.

When does early exercise and an 83(b) election come up?

  • Some startups let you exercise unvested options and file an 83(b) election, which must reach the IRS within 30 days.
  • If the strike equals current fair market value, the taxable spread at that moment is zero, and the holding-period clocks start early.
  • The trade-off is paying cash for shares that could become worthless, and unvested shares are typically repurchased at cost if you leave.
  • Missing the 30-day deadline cannot be fixed, so confirm the filing with a CPA before relying on it.

What else is negotiable?

  • Base salary, sign-on bonus, number of shares, and refresh grants are all common points of negotiation.
  • An extended post-termination exercise window can be as valuable as extra shares if you might leave before an exit.
  • Some candidates trade equity for cash, or vice versa, depending on how much risk their household can carry.
  • Get any negotiated terms in writing in the offer letter or grant documents.

Key takeaways

  • Treat private-company equity as a range of outcomes that includes zero.
  • Ask for strike price, 409A date, fully diluted shares, and liquidation preferences before comparing offers.
  • RSUs, ISOs, and NSOs are taxed differently; review the tax effects with a CPA.
  • Exercise windows, refresh grants, and cash components can matter as much as the share count.